|
It has been a wild college football season so far and the chaos of the BCS does not even arrive until October 18 and we will certainly know a lot more than we do right now. I have spent some time analyzing how the BCS rankings would shake out if they came out today and analysis of what you might see in the middle of October and into November. There are few things to note: 1) Only four (4) of the computer polls are currently public. The Anderson & Hester and Wolfe poll are not out yet. This is important because when factoring in a team's computer ranking, you disregard that teams highest and lowest computer ranking. Because only four are available right now, I did not throw out any scores. 2) The Sagarin Rankings are the only computer poll that also projects how a team will finish in his poll. This is very significant. For example, Oklahoma is currently #27 in the Sagarin, but projected to finish second (behind Florida). 3) I have decided to only use the following teams since I feel they have the most realistic chance to make the BCS Title Game: Florida, Alabama, LSU, Texas, USC, Virginia Tech, Oklahoma, Cincinnati, Boise State, Ohio State, Iowa and TCU. I did not include Michigan, Oregon, Miami (Fla), Penn State, Houston or Oklahoma State (more on these teams in a bit). 4) I have broken the rankings into two polls: 1) composite rankings that use the current Sagarin Rankings (CSR) 2) composite rankings that use the projected Sagarin Rankings (PSR). CSR PSR 1- Florida Florida 2- Alabama Texas 3- Texas Alabama 4- LSU LSU 5- Boise State Boise State 6- Virginia Tech Virginia Tech 7- USC Oklahoma 8- TCU USC 9- Cincinnati Ohio State 10- Oklahoma Cincinnati 11- Ohio State TCU 12- Iowa Iowa ** As I stated, these rankings are a snap shot of what you would see if the BCS announced their rankings today. Beyond this, there is important data to pay attention to. Boise State: Conventional thinking is that four of the teams in front of Boise State are from the SEC and only one team can play for the title; combine that with Texas losing to Oklahoma and you would think Boise State is in the driver’s seat. The problem with that logic is just that...its logical. Boise State seems to have peaked in the computer polls. Despite winning by close to 5 touchdowns on the road last week, they lost ground in three of the four computer polls. The one they stabilized in (Sagarin) is projected to downgrade the Broncos three spots by year’s end. It appears that Boise State's highest projected computer ranking at the end of the season would be Sagarin's #5 and that would be disregarded because of the formula. All indications is that Boise State would finish around #7 or #8 in the final computer rankings. Even if Oregon won out and Boise State finished consensus #1 in the Coaches and Harris Poll's, they would not be in the top two spots in the BCS. Sad reality to how the system works. SEC: I lump in the SEC as one because there is no other way to look at it. Every indication that factors in logic, computer, human polls indicates that the SEC is in. It doesn't matter if it is Florida, LSU or Alabama...as long as the SEC champion has one loss, they are going to Pasadena. I know the next question is what if a two-loss team wins the SEC in an upset, does Boise State get in? The answer is still no. Boise State is out. Texas: Texas is currently in the drivers seat for the second ticket to Pasadena. Oklahoma and Oklahoma State's early losses did them no favors, but the love affair with Texas exists in both the human and computer rankings. Sagarin is the only computer that does not have them in the top five, but that will not matter because that low score will be disregarded. After last year, the human polls are not going to abandon the Horns either, even if Iowa stays undefeated. That bad news for the Horns is they should lose a game from this point on, they would become a long shot with dismal odds to go to Pasadena. Even if they found a way in and won the Big 12 championship, they would need the Big 10, Pac 10 and ACC champions to each have two losses. Iowa: They are a serious contender right now. The computers love them, but the humans are slow to catch on. Currently, they are the top ranked team in the Colley Matrix and Sagarin Rankings (projected to finish 11th). However, unlike Boise State, an undefeated Iowa team would have to beat Michigan and Ohio State. By that time, the human polls would catch on and Sagarin would have Iowa somewhere in his top four spots. It is very conceivable that if both Texas and Iowa win out, Iowa could get in over Texas, but not likely. If Iowa were to be ranked in the top five right now, Texas's lead over them in the overall BCS rankings would be very very very small. Virginia Tech: Currently, the Hokies seem to be the most likely of the one-loss teams to get in (if the Big 10 and Big 12 do not have an undefeated champion). They are downgraded in the Colley Matrix and Massey Polls, but are #5 in the Billingsley and Sagarin Rankings. The Colley and Massey figure to improve and the Billingsley and Sagarin would either improve or stabilize which translates into Virginia Tech being next in line. Right behind them is Oklahoma. Oklahoma: The Sooners did themselves no favors by losing to BYU, but all will be forgotten if they can run the table. The Sagarin Rankings are a good place to get a read on how the computers will judge Oklahoma. If computers had emotions, they would hate Oklahoma right now. Despite the Sagarin Rankings Predictor projecting Oklahoma to finish #2, they are currently #27...and the Colley Matrix currently lists them at #53. Massey ranks them #5 and Billingsley has them at #13. If OU win out (BIG If), the computers will go from hate to love. Assuming they do, Oklahoma can only improve on their Massey ranking and the Colley Matrix ranking would be disregarded. I cannot tell you how each computer would rank OU, but their eligible rankings for the BCS formula would most likely be #2, #2, #3, #4. Remember, if they win out, they would have enough points in the human polls to neutralize the other top notch one loss teams. With that being said, it would be between them and Virginia Tech with the Hokies having the early advantage. USC: I have looked at USC every which way and I don’t see how they would be able to overtake Virginia Tech and Oklahoma if the three should win out. The biggest obstacle facing the Trojans is that both the ACC and Big 12 have an extra game against a quality opponent because of their championship game and that is a huge factor. From a statistical point of view, Virginia Tech, Oklahoma and Ohio State have a higher probability than USC to win out. TCU: The Frogs will have to win the Mountain West to be in the discussion and that would be all they would gain if they did. You can take all of last year's rhetoric with Utah and replace it with TCU. TCU would most likely finish with an average computer score of #5, which would not be enough to get in because the teams in front of them in the computers would also hold the same advantage in the human polls. The Best of the Rest Oregon: The computers really like the Ducks. Billingsley #5, Sagarin #6 (projected #9), Massey #13, Colley #15. If Oregon wins out, they are in the hunt if they can get the human polls to forget about the debacle against Boise State. I don't think Oregon will be able to overcome their status in the human rankings and it is an odd situation because they would have to win out to make the BCS. However, if they beat USC and the other games where they are favored, they are going to be on the first page of the leader board despite having no real shot at BCS title. Michigan: Michigan is currently #3 in the Colley Matrix, but not making much noise with the other computers. Their high Colley ranking would be disregarded and the computers are not going to take a liking to Michigan unless they win all their games. An undefeated Michigan team does not get in over an undefeated Texas team. Michigan is not a player with one loss either. Houston: The best they can hope for is a BCS birth, which is very possible if TCU loses. If Boise State, TCU and Houston all go undefeated, the BCS would probably lock Houston out. There would be too many name programs that the BCS bowl committee would choose over the Cougars. However if either Boise State and TCU should lose and Houston wins out, they would most likely make it. That being said, there is no chance for the Cougars to play for a national title. ** If you have made it this far in the article, you probably have a headache. Don’t worry, I do too. Remember, the rankings are based on current computer projections against the actual human polls. This time next month, either Texas or Oklahoma will be eliminated and the SEC will play itself out in the first weekend of December. Stay tuned. |